Skip to main content

Pitch contests are a lot of fun. The results rarely line up with reality, though. Handing someone a blue ribbon or a giant cardboard check is very different from trading actual cash for a stake in their business.

A 60-second pitch isn’t a campaign to raise capital. A pitch contest is target practice. Raising capital is going to war against a hundred Uzi-toting proctologists. Shooting at a paper target is easy when nobody’s shooting back. It’s a different story when a hundred bandits with rapid-fire weapons are charging at you, and every one of them wants a piece of your ass.

Then there’s Shark Tank, the most unreal reality show on television. Five millionaires sit in leather chairs, the music swells, someone cries about their grandmother’s barbecue sauce recipe, and a deal gets done in ten minutes. Handshake, hug, commercial break. That’s not how the world works. No real investor writes a check because the lighting was good and the theme music hit at the right moment. The show cuts an hour of pitch down to eight minutes of drama. After the cameras leave, plenty of those on-air deals quietly die in due diligence, which the viewers never see. Shark Tank is about as close to real fundraising as The Bachelor is to real marriage.

Speaking of romance: the first pitch in a fundraising campaign is like putting your profile up on Tinder, except you’re not swiping for a hookup. You’re looking for a ten-year marriage with someone who gets a board seat and an opinion about everything you do. Lie on Tinder and the worst that happens is an awkward drink. Lie to an investor, or leave out the important stuff like the fact that you’re married or have no traction, and it will come out. Due diligence is the morning after with the lights on.

When you’re pitching to win a contest, truth, facts and omissions don’t matter as much. The only goal is to impress the judges, and they’ll never get to look under your company’s hood. It’s like Fox News—facts are optional. It’s like winning a slam dunk contest with a trampoline. You might pull off an impressive dunk, but you can’t use a trampoline in basketball, so winning that contest doesn’t make you an NBA player.

Over the past few years I’ve been to plenty of “vanity” pitch contests. The winners deserved to win. Very few of the people pitching ever got funded. Entrepreneurs have better ways to spend their time than putting on a Broadway-worthy multimedia extravaganza.

Pitch contests reward style over substance. Raising money is all substance.

My advice? Build substance. Let your competitors spend their time teaching a bear to dance, or ride a bike, or cry on cue for the Sharks. You go build a business.